Women: please answer this question?

Is it a turn-off is a man takes care of himself extremely well? And I don't mean wearing make-up, or getting manicures or anything like that.

I take extremely good care of myself. Not trying to brag, but I eat the healthiest out of anyone I know, haven't eaten any junk or drank soda or anything but water in over two years. I always wear chapstick especially now that it's the winter and my lips look chapped, I dress very well with fitted and matching clothing, my hair is always brushed to perfection, I'm always clean shaven, etc..

Is it a turnoff? I was looking at myself in the mirror the other day, and thought "Ugh, I look like a woman", mainly because I had like this red chapstick on, which looked like lipstick, and it looked like I wear wearing foundation since my skin is very clear.

Your thoughts?