Which one sounds better?

GIRL 1

Looks

- Cute face, friends think she is hot. Can have good/bad days with looks, mostly good.
- Great body, really toned from working out twice a day, and semi tanned. Way better body than Girl 2
- Caramel blond (not natural), blue eyes, mildly tanned.
- Doesn't bother with make-up or doing herself up.

Intelligence

- Intelligent. Not as smart as Girl 2, and is only smart with a limited range of topics. Doesn't really have definite direction as to what she wants to do with her brain.

Personality

- Happy go lucky character, generally friendly, fun, a good laugh and easy to be around. She's a "fun" girl. Spontaneous and random.
- Funny, good sense of humour, laughs easily and makes me laugh.
- "Good girl", not a wild party animal. Plays it safe.
- Think she's capable of playing games. She plays hard to get with me.
- Caring, friendly nature. Open personality.
- Both tomboy and girly-girl.
- Fun in a spontaneous, happy, random way.

In bed

- Tries some things if I suggest them, and tries enthusiastically. Doesn't really make suggestions on her own though.
- Doesn't really make as much effort as Girl 2, but still gives 100% at what she will do.

CONS

- Not as good in bed. Doesn't do a lot of things, and doesn't like giving BJ's (unlike Girl 2 who loves this)
- Already know she can play games.
- Sometimes really ditzy.
- Falls in love way too easily. Only known her a few weeks and she's got "our song" and says she loves me. She'd probably be crushed if I broke up with her, and wouldn't replace me for a long time.

GIRL 2

Looks

- Stunning face, works as a professional glamour model. Great looks day everyday, even when waking up hungover she's still stunning. Looks on par with a celebrity, much more beautiful than Girl 1 who actually looks plain next to her.
- Alright body. Slender, but not toned, not tanned.
- Natural blond, blue eyed, creamy skinned.
- Spends a lot of time on her looks (for her job), but doesn't look overdone.

Intelligence

- Really intelligent. Knows about most topics, very well educated and well read. Studies law.
- Incredibly articulate. Other people sound stupid next to her

Personality

- Strong, ambitious, determined. You probably wouldn't want to take her on, as she's very passionate and fiery.
- More serious than Girl 1. This girl has real conversations, and has real opinions.
- Wild child underneath it all. Outdrinks the boys, has a Megan Fox type tattoo on her ribs, always up for anything dangerous.
- Doesn't play head games, she's direct and calls it as she sees it. No games.
- Down to earth, does what she says she will, stands by her word, very loyal. Very caring, will look after you if you are sick.
- Mysterious, a bit rebellious.
- Can cook like Jamie Oliver.
- Both a tomboy and a girly girl.
- Super confident, I don't have to prop her up because she's knows she's worth something in her own right.
- More "real woman" whereas Girl 1 is kinda "school-college girl".
- Fun in a she's a challenging, wild-girl who'll try anything way.

In Bed

- Will try anything. You name it, she'll have a go it.
- Has loads of kinky ideas, and really gives it 100% in bed.
- Makes the effort, lingerie, making sure I have a good time etc

Cons
- She's super intimidating, and people have to get to know her before they like her (people automatically lover Girl 1). Once people do get to know her, it's either a love or hate thing.
- She's a complete wild child.
- Brutally honest. Willing to stand up to me.
- Doesn't make me laugh like Girl 2, and she's not as much fun just because she's so smart.
- Knows she's a good catch.
- Doesn't fall easily, she wouldn't flinch if I broke up with her tomorrow. She'd probably have me relaced in a heartbeat, and it'd probably be someone better because she can play the big leagues.
- Other guys hit on her constantly.
- She was easy. She doesn't play hard to get because she believes that this propogates the myth of women being "conquered by men". She puts out easy because shle believes she has sex on her terms only.

NOW HERE'S WHERE WE GET TO THE QUESTION – I really like Girl 1, even her "I love you's" is kinda sweet and makes me melt a little. I'm already cooling it off with Girl 2, but do you think I'm an absolute idiot for doing so? Everyone says Girl 1 doesn't even come close to stacking up to Girl 2 in any area, but I'm into Girl 1 cos she's so easy to be with.

My problem is though that I've been with a tonne of Girl 1's before, and I know I'll get bored of her in a matter of weeks, and will probably end up getting rid of her just because her personality is so run of the mill (yet adorable). I've never known a Girl 2 before, but she's super intimidating, I mean, how do I date a girl like that (she's into me, but she scares me just because she's such a high league girl….she doesn't act like this though, she's actually very no nonsense).

Am I an idiot for writing