Which bar soap would work the best for me?

I have moderately oily skin with mild acne. I have tried a LOT of facial cleansers and whatnot, but the only ones that worked were Cetaphil and Purpose (the bar soap, not the gel cleanser). The only problem I had with the Purpose one was that it did NOTHING to control the oiliness of my skin. The only problem I had with Cetaphil was that it made me break out and it irritated my skin. I tried the Neutrogena facial cleansing bar and it burnt my skin. Literally burned it. I tried the one by Olay and it burned my skin as well.

The only ones I haven't tried are Dove beauty bar, Basis facial bar for sensitive skin, and the Neutrogena facial bar for acne. Which one of these works best? (Oh, and do NOT recommend anything with tea tree oil in it, it makes my skin itch)