What kind of moisturizer should I be using?

I have dry skin right now, because it's winter, and in the summer, my skin gets oily. My t-zone (mostly my nose) will get oily during the day.
I have incredibly sensitive skin and have had allergic reactions to Clinique skin care, Cetaphil, Noxzema, Neutrogena.
I'm currently using Aveeno baby lotion (the oatmeal kind for sensitive skin) on my face, because it's the only thing I haven't had a reaction to, but I feel like it's meant to be a body lotion, not a face lotion. What should I use instead?