Undecided Question

I am 20, I have normal-dry skin, very small pores, and I have never had any form of acne. I am very lucky in this aspect, but for some reason when I use moisturizers and tinted moisturizers, my face "breaks out". I do not break out with acne, but my face gets tiny flesh-colored bumps all over, mostly on my forehead. They are very hard to see, but can be felt easily. I always discontinue use of the product after I notice the bumps, but I have never figured out what actually causes this. Is it an allergic reaction to an ingredient in the moisturizer?

I have only found 1 lotion that does not have this effect: Neutrogena Oil Free Moisture for Sensitive Skin (Without spf… the one with spf gave me bumps). I stopped using because of parabens – I don't like using lotions with chemicals.

I have tried high end, low end, organic, everything I could think of. The following gave me bumps:
Caudalie Antiwrinkle Nourishing Cream ($49), Burt's Bees Radiance Day & Night Cream, Olay spf 15 lotion, pangea organics moisturizer, Stila tinted moisturizer, Laura Mercier Tinted Moisturizer, Juice Beauty Moisturizer….. I know there are more but I can't think of them all.

I have tried finding an ingredient that these products share that may have caused me to get bumps, but I have not been able to identify it.

Does anyone else have this problem, or have any recommendations for moisturizers that do not have parabens, etc that might not give me bumps?